The Lying Game picks up on the night of the twins’ seventeenth birthday after Emma and Ethan have their major confrontation with Sutton. After the party, the couple disovers Sutton has disappeared and the Mercer family car is missing from the garage! "O Twin, Where Art Thou?," the winter premiere of ABC Family’s original series The Lying Game airs Monday, January 2 at 9/8c.

Need to catch up? See how it all began with an all-day The Lying Game marathon starting at 9/8c!