We asked, and you guys voted. The results were insanely close, but we're so excited to announce that Pretty Little Liars' Keegan Allen is our new Weekly Crush! If you love him as much as we do, you definitely don't want to miss this gallery full of some of our favorite pics of Keegan and Toby!
Who do you want to see as the next Weekly Crush from Pretty Little Liars? Let us know in the comments section below -- and keep checking back to see which ABC Family hottie we feature next!
PHOTO CREDIT: Getty Images/Frazer Harrison